That's true - I suppose i'm just dissapointed that this study hasn't seemed to include those within any analysis. Being able to point out that the top 100 calorie counting apps on the app store return similiar results to simple frontier models would be of interest.
I think i'm just dissapointed that this study doesn't go deep enough, and stays at a surface level statistical analysis of frontier models.
I think it’s a very useful study specifically to debunk the apps that support this flow.
None of those apps have magic. They cannot do better than the frontier models.