logoalt Hacker News

knotbinyesterday at 2:35 PM2 repliesview on HN

Yeah that's why Tangled didn't go with ActivityPub (Mastodon protocol) and went with ATproto instead, which is specifically built to solve that problem, so individual servers are all aggregated by centralized AppViews (that anyone can host) that give a singular unified "view" of the network that is just as cohesive as a centralized network feels.


Replies

madamelicyesterday at 2:37 PM

Ah ok! Thanks for digging up info that I didn't go looking for myself. That's fantastic news.

class4behavioryesterday at 3:53 PM

ATProto simply ignores the need for decentralizing incentives on a human/community level. What we get is a sort of a "top-down" federation rather than a grass-roots one. Whoever invests in the infra ends up running a domain.

I mean, practically no one is aware of any other ATPROTO provider other than Bluesky whereas the issue with AP is merely the lack of better implementations, so mastodon.social got the most attention and the hype died off with niche success.

show 1 reply