logoalt Hacker News

ccoyesterday at 8:54 PM2 repliesview on HN

> The same reason Iran is using a lot of drones now. It doesn't seem like the US would be in a conflict where they don't have air superiority.

Hmmm, this sentence appears to be a paradox? Is the US not fighting Iran right now?

Iran has a very weak air force and the US claims air superiority, yet Iran is using a lot of drones.

I think your comment proves GP's point, regardless of traditional air power, drones will feature heavily in any conflict.


Replies

bocyesterday at 9:31 PM

Iranian drones have done nothing to prevent the US and Israel dropping gravity bombs en-mass over their capital right now. JDAMs and unguided munitions are still far cheaper for the explosion size than any drone today. That's not the situation in the Ukraine war on either side.

The US has used one-way "drones" since the 80s or earlier. The entire Gulf War in the early 90s featured a ton of tomahawk cruise missiles. The only real change is that the new shaheeds are way cheaper, slower, and smaller, but can be spammed in larger numbers.

dmixyesterday at 9:35 PM

Iran launched around 2k drones over the war. Ukraine uses around 200k/m.

https://www.kyivpost.com/post/55897

Either way the US needs way more drones instead of just expensive missiles/jets/boats/armor if they are going to face anyone serious like China.