logoalt Hacker News

waychyesterday at 6:48 PM5 repliesview on HN

In the real world, leaving booby traps out that can harm others including the innocent are a liability and regularly a crime in itself.

I wonder how long these sorts of games will play before the law applies itself.


Replies

nmeagentyesterday at 7:13 PM

> I wonder how long these sorts of games will play before the law applies itself.

Perhaps roughly as long as the law turns a blind eye to AI corps flagrantly violating the attribution requirements of software licenses that apply to their training data, as well as basically ignoring other copyright requirements at scale. Fair use, my eye.

marcosdumayyesterday at 7:20 PM

It's Antropic defrauding people here, the person using it for fighting anti-social behavior (or even a troll doing the anti-social behavior themselves) isn't guilty of it.

b00ty4breakfasttoday at 12:21 AM

if someone is trying to use LLM tools in a project that explicitly forbids the use of LLM tools, they are not innocent.

if someone is blinding slurping up content to feed to LLMs, without checking to see if a particular source is OK with that, they are arguably not innocent either.

Neither situation is analogous to a booby-trapped shotgun door blowing off the face of a would-be burglar.

Dylan16807today at 3:12 AM

This is a lot closer to a painting of a poop emoji than a booby trap.

bossyTeacheryesterday at 6:58 PM

>I wonder how long these sorts of games will play before the law applies itself.

Whose law? Good luck trying to summon a random GitHub user to a court within your jurisdiction.

show 1 reply