logoalt Hacker News

ogogmadyesterday at 7:36 PM2 repliesview on HN

Iran has said that it's working on nuclear energy, not a bomb. Their pope-level religious leader said it was haram to have nuclear weapons. I know you can't necessarily trust Iran's word, but can you trust Israel's?


Replies

colechristensenyesterday at 9:15 PM

There is ZERO serious questioning that Iran was working on developing nuclear weapons. It is abundantly clear that they were. How actively and to what extent in recent years is a matter of some debate but in general they absolutely have had a serious weapons program.

show 1 reply
maratcyesterday at 9:38 PM

I've never received any answer to the question "what legitimate non-military use is there for a 60%-plus enriched uranium?"

The nuclear reactors can provide free electricity out of 2-5% enriched uranium, the naval propulsion (like for ... nuclear icebreakers for the Straits of Hormuz, I dunno?) needs 8-10% enriched.

It doesn't matter what they say, or what their leaders say -- there is only one use for 60%+ enriched uranium known to the science, and it's military (the atomic bomb).