logoalt Hacker News

Executable installer will stop being released with Python 3.16

31 pointsby ankitg12today at 7:25 AM24 commentsview on HN

Comments

proactivesvcstoday at 9:49 AM

With this change of policy the foundation does not "have any control or influence over what WinGet does", one of the first class methods to install python.

https://github.com/python/pymanager/issues/287

Alifatisktoday at 9:43 AM

> To install using WinGet, the command is "winget install 9NQ7512CXL7T"

Is the package name on purpose?

show 4 replies
PeterStuertoday at 10:41 AM

I've been using uv to manage python with great success, but yeah, now that Astral has been aquired, it sort of makes me a little bit uneasy I admit.

lostmsutoday at 11:35 AM

WinGet and potentially MSIX have a glaring hole that should make this a no-no: programs installed that way don't work correctly via native Windows SSH server. If I remember correctly, the scenarios that fail are: installing using WinGet via SSH fails, updating using WinGet via SSH breaks the executable shims, and if Windows Store updates package, you can't use executable shims from SSH until reboot.

greatgibtoday at 9:13 AM

> Python install manager will automatically update within a day of an update being released

Totally something that someone in his right mind will not want to.

Also impatiently waiting for the day that the org will be blocked on the store so that the morons that decided that can be rewarded...

Also, how can you do an offline install?

show 1 reply
alexaholictoday at 12:13 PM

> winget install 9NQ7512CXL7T

LOL

immanuwelltoday at 9:47 AM

rip to the .exe installer - honestly overdue, since python on windows has been a rite of passage in suffering for too long, and leaning into winget/store is the right call

dartharvatoday at 8:50 AM

They should honestly just instead back `scoop` as the default way to install Python on Windows. It's clean, sits nicely in userspace and handles CLI execution aliases elegantly.

RS-232today at 11:33 AM

This is pretty terrible for offline deployment. An install manager is useless for offline systems.

For folks who don’t want any hassles, there’s WinPython. It’s a portable Python distribution à la Anaconda. The “whl” flavor includes a nice wheelhouse of packages that you can use as a flat index for your venvs.

znpytoday at 10:46 AM

> To install using WinGet, the command is winget install 9NQ7512CXL7T.

so ergonomic!

crabbonetoday at 9:35 AM

[flagged]

show 2 replies
SuperHeavy256today at 9:05 AM

So now you're forced to use Microslop Store to get Python? At the very least they could offer .msix files to download and use.

show 1 reply