logoalt Hacker News

Eddy_Viscosity2today at 2:42 PM1 replyview on HN

Medical professionals have a history of not necessarily having complete understanding of the maths they use in their work. Classic example of a nutritionist 'inventing' the trapezoid rule for calculating area under a curve, and then naming it after herself. And then many many other medical people unironically using said method and citing her.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tai%27s_model


Replies

bbortoday at 2:45 PM

A) these aren’t “medical people”, they’re neuroscientists and psychologists. Comparing them to a nutritionist seems especially cruel!

B) “some people have been wrong before” is not a reason to think you know better than the authors of an upcoming Nature article based on a few layperson-targeted paragraphs summarizing the paper from a very high level.

show 1 reply