logoalt Hacker News

OptionOfTyesterday at 8:19 PM2 repliesview on HN

As a 37 year old male with 2 THRs I'm glad the AI was NOT used in my diagnosis. All the models that I used to look at my x-rays said nothing was wrong, even when adding symptoms. When adding age it said the patient was too young.

(I was ~3 months away from wheelchair bound in those x-rays).

The worst one was Gemini. Upload an x-ray of just the right hip, and it started to talk about how good the left hip looked like.

I think with AI taking over it's gonna be harder to get a solution when your problem isn't the run-of-the mill.


Replies

cyberaxyesterday at 8:47 PM

The general AI models are useless if you need precision. They are designed to create/analyze pretty pictures.

But specialized models can be inhumanly good. I know, our main product is a model that does _precise_ analysis :)

show 1 reply
jeffbeeyesterday at 8:24 PM

All versions and levels of Gemini have terrible spatial reasoning. I don't know why. That kind of task seems to be simply outside of the abilities of the model.