logoalt Hacker News

xyzelementyesterday at 9:07 PM6 repliesview on HN

It took me a minute to figure out why I think it's lame.

I suspect that Banksy and his fans are sure that it's "the other" Britons that are blinded, it's not a self-reflection prompt for them. Maybe I am wrong.

Maybe a more powerful piece of art would have that self reflection effect across the board. As is it feels about as nuanced as "fuck trump" and similar. If you already agree you already agree, if not then you just think it's stupid. So ultimately feels like impotent art unless I am totally misunderstanding.


Replies

ninjagooyesterday at 11:13 PM

> It took me a minute to figure out why I think it's lame.

> Maybe a more powerful piece of art would have that self reflection effect across the board. As is it feels about as nuanced as "fuck trump" and similar. If you already agree you already agree, if not then you just think it's stupid.

So close. Based on your own statement, it appears that you disagree with the proposed thesis by this piece of art.

> So ultimately feels like impotent art unless I am totally misunderstanding.

Maybe you should re-examine why you think it is stupid/lame. Is it because it calls you out and you don't like that feeling?

show 1 reply
lschuelleryesterday at 9:20 PM

So many people connect this to political topics... For me this is the genius thing about the statue. Seems to be, that quite a lot people are so wrapped up in political debates and political positions, that it has to have political meaning. Maybe this statue is the exact opposit thing of a political message.

lucketoneyesterday at 9:55 PM

Is it that important to decode what author thought when he was making it?

What if the design was made by generative model, does the statue become more or less valuable?

fyloyesterday at 9:28 PM

Are you trying to be ironic?

delusionalyesterday at 9:28 PM

Yet us talking about it just prompted me to consider how that applies to my life, so something good came of it :)

LightBug1yesterday at 10:01 PM

I don't think it's impotent at all.

I think you're wildly overestimating the general population's capacity for nuance.

Particularly in a world where nuance goes the same way as wood logs near a fire place.