logoalt Hacker News

cyanydeezyesterday at 10:00 PM0 repliesview on HN

This makes sense, but you need to understand that you're ignoring the compiler once you're past the machine code level which isn't an abstraction right, it's the root. So ignoring that part of the missive, goin from C to Python, different compilers do add different machine code.

C and Python have a bunch of different compilers, so you don't if you take the same code, the f' output can be different. There's determinism within the same compiler. Add in different architectures, and the machine code output definitely is more varied than presented.

But that's still a manageable; then what if you add in all the dependencies, well you get a more florid complexity.

So really, it's a shitty abstraction rather than an inaccurate analogy. If you lined them up in levels, there could be some universe where they are a valid abstraction. But it's not the current universe, because we know the models function on non-determinism.

I'd posit if there was a 'turtles all the way down' abstraction for the LLM, it's simply coming from the other end, the one where human mind might start entering the picture.