logoalt Hacker News

Legend2440today at 12:34 AM1 replyview on HN

I don't agree with this take. Determinism is a nice property for abstractions to have, but it isn't necessary to be an abstraction.

And LLMs can handle very abstract concepts that could not possibly be encoded in C++, like the user's goal in using software.


Replies

farmdawgnationtoday at 1:25 AM

I think you could also make the case that the existing abstractions aren't actually fully deterministic themselves. The compiler or interpreter may not behave as it should. Therefore, for any correct C code, there's probability that the GCC compiler will turn it into correctly formed machine code. But it may not!

Is the probability much higher with GCC? Sure. But it's still a probability.

show 1 reply