logoalt Hacker News

krioryesterday at 8:01 PM5 repliesview on HN

Can someone from the US explain what race even means in this context and how it is determined?


Replies

_--__--__yesterday at 8:20 PM

It is self reported according to the US census recognized racial categories: white, black, asian, native American/Alaskan, native Hawaiian or Pacific islander, and other (or two+ categories). Hispanic/latino identification is a separate box you check for reasons that are hard to explain without going over decades of bureaucratic decisions.

show 1 reply
nomelyesterday at 8:33 PM

All levels of the US education system teach (now at least) that race is a social construct. There's no concept of population-genetics taught, until much later, in hard science classes.

BowBunyesterday at 8:12 PM

Yes, this is a common point of confusion when talking to Europeans about racial issues in the US (as I found out myself recently). Race in our contexts refers to your background/birthplace/heritage. On our government forms: "What race are you?" "White, black, hispanic, etc."

This is fundamentally different by intent than in Europe (using french here) where we refer to 'la race humaine' which is the _species_.

The nuance is critical during debates. While I was discussing racial differences to some Swiss folks, they thought I was talking Nazi propaganda! We are all part of the human species, the human species has many races. We are all equal!

show 3 replies
ButlerianJihadyesterday at 8:36 PM

There are various risk factors, and some lab tests, that differ among racial groups.

For example, my labs include at least two that have different specified thresholds for "African-American" or "non-AA" patients.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sickle_cell_disease#United_Sta...

durkieyesterday at 8:09 PM

i believe it is self-declared.