logoalt Hacker News

zozbot234yesterday at 8:11 PM1 replyview on HN

Sure but the OP suggests that these were minor gains, and that this limited scope for gains was necessary in order to preserve the quality standard that's long been expected in that FLOSS community. We aren't talking about either a 10x productivity gain or one-shotting entire new features from scratch.

This is arguably a key quote: "Then, it was time to read all the code, line by line. ... I found many small inefficiencies or design errors ... so I started a process of manual and AI-assisted rewrite of many modules." We should not underestimate that step: reading code line by line might easily require more time than writing it from scratch.


Replies

simonwyesterday at 8:33 PM

Right, and those of us who advocate for a sensible approach to agentic engineering don't talk about 10x productivity gains or one-shotting entire new (production-ready) features from scratch either.

I remain unconvinced by the "faster to write it by hand than read it" arguments though. My experience throughout my career is that most people, myself included, top out at a couple of hundred lines of tested, production-ready code per day. I can productively review a couple of thousand.

show 2 replies