logoalt Hacker News

TimTheTinkeryesterday at 6:08 PM4 repliesview on HN

I reject the premise that the universe, the earth, and human existence is without purpose. It's one premise among several, and not one I subscribe to.

At least 80% of people agree with me, so I'm not holding to a fringe idea.


Replies

goatloveryesterday at 10:32 PM

Do Hindus and Buddhists generally agree there is a purpose? Perhaps too escape suffering and reincarnation? Sounds more like a western theistic view of existence. Like the deity has a plan for everyone's life kind of thing.

semiquaveryesterday at 6:33 PM

I didn’t say any such thing like the universe has no purpose. Merely that in a scientific sense evolution has no motivation. It is an emergent phenomenon which tends to maximize fitness to reproduce and cannot be said to do anything for a reason. Saying otherwise is just anti-science.

moffkalastyesterday at 9:57 PM

Well yes because just like your earlier point, we can't help but anthropomorphise the world around us.

Just like we see a person in an LLM, it's easy to assume that because we create things with a purpose, that the world around us also has to be that way. But it's just as wrong and arguably far more dangerous.

jplusequaltyesterday at 7:08 PM

>At least 80% of people agree with me, so I'm not holding to a fringe idea.

Appeal to majority much?

show 3 replies