logoalt Hacker News

ipythonyesterday at 8:57 PM6 repliesview on HN

Just gonna say... Aaron Swartz faced years of prison time and ultimately decided to take his own life... for downloading scientific journal articles... to share freely with the world (aka not even profiting from it).

But a multi-billion dollar corporation downloading millions of copyrighted creative works so that they can reshape the entire labor market by training a new type of artificial intelligence model on that data set? Meh, sounds like Silicon Valley disruption, give the man a medal!


Replies

spongebobstoesyesterday at 11:50 PM

Aaron Swartz was treated unjustly because copyright sucks. we should oppose such laws and treatment, not wield them as retributive tools against our opponents

it is wrong to advocate for everyone to be treated equally unjustly. better to advocate for the removal of the bad laws/structures

show 1 reply
lesuoracyesterday at 10:59 PM

And Jstor dropped the lawsuit when Aaron deleted his local copy. DOJ didn't drop theirs.

I doubt Meta has deleted their local copy though ...

show 2 replies
defenyesterday at 11:39 PM

One man illegally downloading copyrighted material is a crime. Multinational corporations illegally downloading copyrighted material is the only remaining growth area in the US economy and vital to national security.

Melatonicyesterday at 9:50 PM

Truly ahead of his time

zajio1amyesterday at 11:22 PM

Well, Meta also shared their AI models freely with world

alex1138yesterday at 9:23 PM

Had Aaron copied Snapchat 5 times the DOJ would've been fine with it all. His fault for not having the foresight

show 1 reply