logoalt Hacker News

prependtoday at 3:09 PM1 replyview on HN

This is coming from github’s status page. You need to reconcile memory of downtime with github’s official record.

I’ve been using github pretty much daily since 2010 and I never had a push fail or a repo be unavailable until recently.


Replies

sarchertechtoday at 4:47 PM

I can tell you that graph is full of shit because you can go back through recorded incidents here

https://www.githubstatus.com/history

And immediately find that there are numerous incidents that would show up on the modern status board as an issue but are reported with 100.00000% uptime on that graph.

One example:

https://www.githubstatus.com/incidents/bzj1hc2cnfkc

2018-07-16 17:32:53 - We are investigating reports of elevated error rates.

2018-07-16 17:34:27 - We are investigating reports of service unavailability.

2018-07-16 18:04:38 - We've discovered the issue causing connectivity failures and are remediating.

2018-07-16 18:26:48 - We're monitoring the site as systems recover. Some delays are expected as we process backlogged data.

2018-07-16 18:37:26 - We're continuing to monitor and work on further remediation efforts as the site recovers.

2018-07-16 18:54:21 - The site is stable. We are continuing to monitor and work through follow-up remediation efforts.

And there are other incidents with connection failures or elevated error rates during July 2018, but the linked graph shows "average uptime of all components 100.00000%" during July 2018.

Another from October (that also shows 100.0000% uptime)

2018-10-21 23:09:19 - We are investigating reports of elevated error rates.

2018-10-21 23:13:31 - We are investigating reports of service unavailability.

2018-10-21 23:43:55 - We're investigating problems accessing GitHub.com.

2018-10-22 00:05:37 - We're failing over a data storage system in order to restore access to GitHub.com.

2018-10-22 00:23:54 - We're continuing to work on migrating a data storage system in order to restore access to GitHub.com.

2018-10-22 00:43:12 - We continue to work on migrating a data storage system in order to restore access to GitHub.com.

2018-10-22 01:02:49 - We continue to migrate a data storage system in order to restore full access to GitHub.com.

2018-10-22 01:22:22 - We continue to work to migrate a data storage system in order to restore access to GitHub.com.

2018-10-22 01:41:19 - We are continuing to work to migrate a data storage system in order to restore access to GitHub.com.

>I’ve been using github pretty much daily since 2010 and I never had a push fail or a repo be unavailable until recently.

Looking back at their downtime history. Unless recently is within the last 3 years, it seems like you got really lucky.