logoalt Hacker News

hermitShelltoday at 4:19 PM4 repliesview on HN

If you like sci-fi takes on software systems, check out Vernor Vinge "A Fire upon the deep" and sequels. I recall ship systems software is something like all the code humanity has ever written, plus centuries of LLM churn. One of the protagonists is a space faring software developer particularly good with legacy code.

We are used to thinking about software like in the article, a program that runs deterministically in an OS. Where we are headed might be more like where the LLM or AI system is the OS, and accomplishes things we want through a combination of pre-written legacy software, and perhaps able to accomplish new things on the fly.


Replies

genghisjahntoday at 4:30 PM

Interesting, I kinda do this. Sometimes when an LLM solves a problem for me, I have it write code so that I can reuse that exact same approach deterministically(and I line by line check it). Now I have about a dozen CLI commands that the LLM can use and I'm reasonably (although not 100%) sure I'll get an expected outcome. Really helpful with debugging via steam pipe and connecting to read replicas.

genghisjahntoday at 7:30 PM

Ordered Fire Upon the Deep. Looks interesting.

Izkatatoday at 4:35 PM

Sounds like a recipe for Star Trek holodeck malfunctions.

DonHopkinstoday at 4:54 PM

Pham Nuwen is a master of vibe patching legacy sedimentary software.