logoalt Hacker News

rmunntoday at 12:38 AM2 repliesview on HN

In BASIC? Why? Why would you do that to yourself?

Don't get me wrong, if he enjoys writing code in BASIC, I'm not going to tell him to stop having fun. It would be silly to tell some random stranger "You're having fun wrong!" (Even if I totally think he's having fun wrong. Grin). If he's having fun with it, go for it.

But man, I looked at the code and got flashbacks. The bad kind. BASIC was the first language I learned when I was a kid, and it's what taught me programming (because after typing "LOAD WIZARD.BAS", I could type "LIST" instead of typing "RUN" and I could actually see what the program was doing. So I learned by reading other people's code. And The Wizard's Castle was pretty good for a BASIC program: it had subroutines, a multi-dimensional map stored in a single-dimensional array (and an actual function defined to convert X,Y,Z coordinates to an index in the array!), and so on. So I am grateful to BASIC for teaching me programming.

And I never, never, NEVER want to write another line of BASIC code again in my life.

But if he enjoys doing so, good for him. I'll just sit here muttering under my breath "But he's still having fun wrong"... :-)


Replies

joblessjunkietoday at 2:21 AM

Laughing agreement. I’m very sentimental for BASIC.

By the standard of getting kids started it’s an amazing and wildly successful language.

By any other standard, it is absolutely terrible! It commits every famous programming sin! Stay away! Do not learn from this language! LOL

icedchaitoday at 12:53 AM

I haven't written BASIC since I was a teenager! The more "modern" basics, without line numbers, were a definite improvement. I went from AppleSoft to AmigaBasic and QuickBasic.

show 1 reply