logoalt Hacker News

0xDEAFBEADtoday at 2:42 AM4 repliesview on HN

Commentators: "America's young are addicted to their phones, hopelessly politically polarized, and socially illiterate. Test scores are dropping and critical thinking skills are at an all-time low. They hate and fear the other gender, mainline conspiracy theory podcasts, struggle with anxiety, were coddled from birth, etc. etc."

Also commentators: "The elderly have to go. We need fresh blood."

(Yes I acknowledge there is a middle position where you elect 45-year-olds who came of age before the internet yet are still reasonably sharp mentally. I just think it's interesting that the two narratives above seem to coexist so easily.)


Replies

tdb7893today at 2:06 PM

The first commentators are talking mostly about gen-z and gen-alpha nowadays while the second group of commentators wants gen-x or millennials to have power finally. These aren't really opposite takes at all (and if you're talking about test scores and conspiratorial thinking boomers seem to be worse than gen-x and millennials in my experience so in many ways these commentaries are not only not oppositional but actually compatible).

Terr_today at 2:45 AM

But are they the same commentators each time?

show 1 reply
jandrewrogerstoday at 3:10 AM

Honestly, 45 year olds will probably have some of the most objective views across that reality.

show 1 reply
jmulltoday at 3:26 AM

It's almost like there are different people out there with different ideas about things.