logoalt Hacker News

CrzyLngPwdyesterday at 7:01 PM7 repliesview on HN

It seems to me that adding AI to desktop apps and sending the data back to the mothership for processing is an amazing way to collect data from people who, for the most part, would be completely unaware it's even happening.

Heck, most of them think the Internet is Chrome.


Replies

GeekyBearyesterday at 8:15 PM

> adding AI to desktop apps and sending the data back to the mothership for processing is an amazing way to collect data from people

Wasn't that the entire point of Windows Recall as well?

show 2 replies
Foobar8568yesterday at 8:38 PM

You mean that chrome is an internet explorer?

show 5 replies
UltraSanetoday at 12:03 AM

I once had someone ask me why closing the web browser turned off his Internet

rishabhaioveryesterday at 7:17 PM

It would be a reasonable deduction for someone who doesn't have the time or interest to understand the internals.

2ndorderthoughtyesterday at 8:58 PM

I called this out when it was announced on here. Supposedly the team lead replied to my comment saying this wouldn't happen. I rolled my eyes but asked will android be able to use those models for ex filtration. No reply. And apparently the original claim was not true either lol.

Maybe I'm misremembering it. Google is awful. My goodness. I hate Android and can't wait to be rid of it. Graphene and it's buddies can't roll it fast enough

show 1 reply
j45yesterday at 10:32 PM

I'm just not sure how this gives me control of my information, whether I want it sent or not to Google, and if they're retaining it for training or not.

That last question I don't even want to ask because the first two doesn't seem clear.

This could be simply fixed by adding the feature, and defaulting it off, and letting people learn about it and enable it.

show 1 reply
ProllyInfamousyesterday at 8:07 PM

The even more frustrating thing here is that after auto-updates everything new [including AI "features"] is turned ON by default.

I do like how Firefox now has a "prevent future AI integrations" checkbox[0], but I just don't believe it anymore (i.e. that it won't magically `uncheck` itself and then enable features I've not requested/authorized).

Which is why I just used an LLM to help me create a local network admin rule to disable the update engine entirely (this SHOULD. NOT. BE. NECESSARY).

[•] <https://www.perplexity.ai/search/b0d3bf5d-7ac7-4d4c-b6c6-32b...>

[0] with a sick darkpattern (for most users to laregly ignore)

show 1 reply