logoalt Hacker News

jasonwatkinspdxtoday at 4:34 AM2 repliesview on HN

We have overwhelming evidence that corporal punishment is harmful in general, and very harmful for kids.

As someone that was on the receiving end of that kind of violence due to growing up in a fundamentalist evangelical family, I will not mince words: the view you have expressed is pure evil. I simplly cannot imagine the mentality that kids need to be physically tortured to learn how to behave.


Replies

dash2today at 6:13 AM

>We have overwhelming evidence that corporal punishment is harmful in general, and very harmful for kids.

This is false. The evidence is not overwhelming; it's actually extremely poor quality. And the research question is one of the most difficult to resolve in social science. I wrote on this here: https://wyclif.substack.com/p/the-academic-literature-on-sma.... See also this guy: https://scholar.google.co.uk/citations?hl=en&user=2HtqmZ0AAA...

show 2 replies
invalidSyntaxtoday at 4:46 AM

Yeah my bad. I was the getting bullied side of students, but the current punishments are something that should be ended.