logoalt Hacker News

tardedmemeyesterday at 9:03 PM2 repliesview on HN

If you run a website, it seems trivial to forward the attestation to someone else by putting the same code up on your website, and getting their device banned from google instead of your own.


Replies

coppsilgoldyesterday at 11:09 PM

Realistically, what Google will do in such a scenario is collect data about the illicit service, enumerate the devices the farm uses and what other activities the devices participate in. What you suggested has far less control over the devices that generate the attestations and it will show.

Also, if the implementation is competently done the phone will show the website for which you scanned the QR code. A user would be able to see whether or not that matches the site where they observed the QR code and proceed accordingly. In time Google will probably integrate it into the Chrome browser where a proxied QR code cannot even be shown.

ChadNauseamyesterday at 10:42 PM

The domain in the attestation would be yours, so that wouldn't work

show 2 replies