logoalt Hacker News

incrediblylargetoday at 6:03 AM1 replyview on HN

A month ago my PhD supervisor told me it rips on proofs but he also said it's useless when formalising arguments in Lean - is this still the case?


Replies

vjerancrnjaktoday at 6:09 AM

Nope. Codex formalizes much better than any tool with exception of Aristotle from Harmonic.

https://github.com/vjeranc/fixed-rtrt

M3 module was formalized fully purely from experimental data and from a nudge by earlier versions of codex in 15-30 minutes in a simple write/compile/fix-first-error loop. I was a bit surprised how fast it picked up the pattern but given there was a paper from '70s it became clear why later.