alt Hacker NewsBack in the day it was reasonably common for CMSs and forums to only have an index.php, and routing entirely by query string (in form-urlencoded form, people were not savages). So you would have index.php?p=home and index.php?p=shop. Or index.php?action=showthread&forum=42&thread=17976. It should be immediately obvious that in that scheme 404 is indeed the correct answer to unknown query parameters
In fact lots of sites still work like that, they just hide it behind a couple rewrite rules in apache/nginx for SEO reasons
Replies
> It should be immediately obvious that in that scheme 404 is indeed the correct answer to unknown query parameters
That's not obvious at all. If I receive json data that contains a property I'm not aware of, i don't reject the entire document for that reason. In the case of query strings, extra query parameters might be used by other parts of the stack besides yours, so rejecting the entire document because someone somewhere else is trying to pass information to itself is the wrong approach.
Oh no, looks like my old forum software urls.
watch?v=oHg5SJYRHA0
If you're routing like it's 1999, sure, 404.
On the other hand, if it's a CRUD app and you're filtering a list of entities by various field values? Returning that no items matched your selection (or an empty list, if an API) makes more sense than a 404, which would more appropriate for an attempt to pull up a nonexistent entity URI.