logoalt Hacker News

MBCooktoday at 12:27 AM3 repliesview on HN

It’s starting to feel like we may need to go back to the model where you need to be invited to be able to submit code or PRs. The barrier is just too low now for popular projects.


Replies

x-complexitytoday at 2:28 AM

Forks need to be normalized again.

Logistically & brand-wise, they're messy to deal with, but they result in a "filter" of sorts that the original project can pick & choose to upstream back into their code.

show 1 reply
jonhohletoday at 1:45 AM

It’s not just popular projects. On a small utility I have I received a PR that was more lines than the project had. I’m happy to be a good maintainer, but reviewing something that’s effectively an AI rewrite isn’t something I care to review and since I can’t vet it, can’t blindly accept it.

show 1 reply
hsbauauvhabzbtoday at 1:01 AM

I think some sort of reputation score would make more sense, assuming it’s possible to design one that can’t be easily faked

show 1 reply