logoalt Hacker News

herskotoday at 6:18 PM6 repliesview on HN

[flagged]


Replies

artnanikatoday at 6:42 PM

What a bizarre thing to say, concentration camps during the Holocaust also had swimming pools and soccer fields (for the inmates as well), does that prove the Holocaust is a hoax? Swimming pools, soccer fields, and 5k events do not disprove ongoing genocides.

show 1 reply
_alternator_today at 6:28 PM

Honestly it's difficult for me to respond to this comment because the premise is so clearly flawed.

A semblance of civilian life does not mean genocide did not or is not taking place. Wholesale population displacement, destruction of a significant percentage of civilian structures, bombings, raids, land and sea blockades, statements from leaders that suggest genocidal intent... these point in the other direction.

Would it only be genocide only if no child in Gaza was smiling? If no one was getting married, no one singing, no one relaxing amid the horror? Inhumanity of this level of extreme only occurs literally when everyone is dead. I guess that's the line you have in mind?

show 2 replies
rexpoptoday at 6:24 PM

It was held in the U.S., not in Gaza, at Nethermead Lawn in Prospect Park, Brooklyn.

There are also other Gaza 5K events in U.S. cities, including Dallas and Milwaukee, depending on the year and location.

show 2 replies
b00ty4breakfasttoday at 6:47 PM

See, the thing that makes a genocide is all the dead people. The dead people who were killed by Israeli missiles and bombs. Or when they, the Israeli military, denied aid workers entry into the steaming heap of rubble that they, the Israeli military, created with their missiles and bombs. The steaming heap of rubble that used to be populated buildings that they, the Israeli military, bombed into powder whilst people were inside of them.

pnemonictoday at 6:28 PM

[flagged]

show 2 replies
dpoloncsaktoday at 6:21 PM

[flagged]

show 2 replies