logoalt Hacker News

Clusters become personal (like PCs did)

42 pointsby druidlast Tuesday at 11:12 PM32 commentsview on HN

Comments

skybriantoday at 5:40 PM

The article assumes there are people who want clusters. But a single Linux VM in the cloud can scale pretty far. Separate VM's for different apps works well for isolation. Why do I need a cluster?

show 6 replies
JustinGarrisontoday at 7:53 PM

I'm actually confused about what ClusterdOS is and does besides glue a bunch of projects together in an opinionated way.

It sits on top of Kubernetes and seems very hand wavy about how you create and manage those clusters.

show 1 reply
MobiusHorizonstoday at 5:41 PM

Wouldn’t it be cheaper / less complex to scale vertically (eg a large workstation or medium size bare metal server) instead of using clusters? My understanding is that clusters are primarily useful when you want to share a resource from a pool across unpredictable usage, which becomes a moot point once the cluster is personal.

wrstoday at 6:38 PM

I’m not sure quite what this is trying to say. My laptop is already a personal cluster — it has 16 cores, lots of storage, a fast network, I run VMs on it. It’s been the case for a long time that you can run bursty jobs in the cloud if you need more power for a brief period than whatever is currently locally affordable. That’s kind of what the cloud is for, really. So what’s new?

show 1 reply
alex_youngtoday at 7:44 PM

Clusters are almost never the right answer for most problems: https://yourdatafitsinram.net/

show 2 replies
aliasxneotoday at 6:43 PM

No idea about ClusterOS, but I would recommend IncusOS if you're looking for a nice clustering solution. Incus has become indispensable in my homelab over the past few months. It's what I put on my bare metal machines and then spin up Talos Linux VMs for day job practice.

show 2 replies
Ancapistanitoday at 6:51 PM

The best part of this article is in the footnotes:

> see CEO of Tailscale apenwarr's vibe-researched thread

“Vibe-research” is now a core part of my vocabulary.

0fflineusertoday at 8:50 PM

Does anyone now what is the font used in the article? I like ut a lot.

throwatdem12311today at 7:38 PM

Buddy 90% of people can’t even open a word document without immense stress

gizajobtoday at 7:15 PM

Imagine a Beowulf cluster of these!

DeathArrowtoday at 7:01 PM

I don't see how an operating system can work for a cluster.

You can have more than one CPU and more than one storage connected to one mainboard and that works because the interconnect fabric is very fast.

We don't have have the possibility to connect different computers at the same kind of speed that would let them work together seamlessly.

show 2 replies
lowbloodsugartoday at 6:30 PM

I have an irrational soft spot for Apache Mesos. I loved the separation of the resource management from the scheduling. Note to self: do not rabbit hole on this. Hm. Maybe mesos is the manager for my agent sandboxes. No! Bad lowbloodsugar!