logoalt Hacker News

irishcoffeetoday at 3:49 PM3 repliesview on HN

This gets so old. Rust is a programming language. It does some things really well, some things less so. It isn't a panacea, it's a tool. People can use it because they like it, right-tool-for-the-job or not. People can hate it, hating a programming language is one of the most benign things to hate in the whole world. "Language-ist" is a world I never want to live in.

Feels like there are some people who love rust, and some people who hate rust, and most everyone else doesn't give a shit. Everyone is right and everyone is wrong, depending on who you ask.

Can't we just go back to the emacs vs vi debate? Is that the itch people are trying to scratch?


Replies

traderj0etoday at 4:06 PM

The post doesn't hate on Rust, it's more saying you probably shouldn't use it for high-level code like a web backend. Which is pretty reasonable.

show 2 replies
mwigdahltoday at 3:59 PM

vi would be much easier to rewrite in Rust.

show 1 reply
scuff3dtoday at 4:18 PM

The annoying thing about Rust, or at least the hype around Rust, is that people want to in use it for bloody everything.

We have absolutely no need for it at work. We're writing micro services that run in K8s with no extreme performance requirements. Nobody on the team knows the language (I know it better than the people arguing for it, and I don't know more then the basics). And yet, every couple of weeks, I'm having to talk someone out of switching certain services over to it. It's like a damn disease.

show 1 reply