logoalt Hacker News

ceejayozyesterday at 10:45 PM1 replyview on HN

“X is or is not medically necessary” seems like a decision a medical professional should determine, no? Subject to licensing and liability?

If I build you a house and tell you the roof trusses aren’t necessary, you’d be pretty peeved.


Replies

rainsfordtoday at 12:00 AM

I think the right analogy here is that I'm a renter and the person who built my house (builder) is different from the person who paid for the house (landlord). The builder said the roof needed trusses but the landlord decided they weren't "structurally necessary" and refused to pay for them. The roof collapses on me...does the landlord escape liability?

Maybe an even better analogy is that I live in a rented home and after I report some weird respiratory issues, an inspector finds black mold all over the place. The landlord refuses to fix the issue because "black mold is totally fine, bro" and I get really sick. I could maybe have moved out, but I kinda feel like the landlord is going to have a bad time here.

show 1 reply