logoalt Hacker News

fullstoptoday at 1:50 PM7 repliesview on HN

Has the USA's potash supply been reduced due to strained relations with Canada? They are our top supplier, by far.


Replies

metiscustoday at 1:54 PM

Fertilizer is pretty fungible and is a global market, so even if the US is primarily supplied by Canada, and overall global demand remained constant, prices would go up since there will be supply reduction due to the Hormuz strait being closed.

8notetoday at 7:53 PM

i dont think canada has had any drop in potash sales to the south. the main potash producers are even planning new US ports for exporting potash to global markets through.

which itself is a major factor - the US imports tons of potash from canada, only to re-export it elsewhere. a clampdown from canada would be more likely to hit a south korea or china more than the midwest

HarHarVeryFunnytoday at 3:17 PM

A lot of crops need nitrogen. What has been impacted by Trump's Iran war is the supply of Urea through the Straight of Hormuz.

If the closure persists then no doubt other sources can ramp up to fill the void, but it's going to be too late for this season. Some Asian farmers have already chosen not to bother planting rice crops since the increase in fertilizer (urea) cost has meant they'd be losing money.

Fuel prices are also impacting imported produce prices.

koverstreettoday at 1:51 PM

Are you forgetting the nitrogen? :)

show 2 replies
SecretDreamstoday at 2:17 PM

Yes. Despite what others have said, yes. But, in general, because of the current global dynamics, fertilizer is more expensive wherever you're going to be getting it from. It just doesn't help that the US has picked a trade war with all allies at the same time, while also engaging in real wars that disrupt global supply chains of critical resources.

show 1 reply
sandworm101today at 6:05 PM

US and Canadian production is largely irrelevant to the price. These are world comodities. If worldwide production drops, prices rise. As with oil/gas producers, domestic potash producers are under no obligation to sell locally. If prices are higher in europe/asia/africa, that domestic potash will be loaded onto ships until domestic prices rise to match.

show 1 reply
colechristensentoday at 2:03 PM

It's the nitrogen fertilizer almost all of which is manufactured from methane + air.

show 1 reply