logoalt Hacker News

patconyesterday at 11:11 PM1 replyview on HN

A citation is where you derived knowledge... If you haven't checked it and you are submitting something that should represent a ton of labour (and which will consume labour to review), you don't understand what you're doing. It is not just crossing T's and dotting I'd.

Your being set behind is less important than the fact that your publishing is setting everyone else behind.

Such a banned person is being helped to "step out of the way", and someone more competent will assuredly step forward to consume the limited maintenance labour more thoughtfully


Replies

dataflowyesterday at 11:16 PM

> Your being set behind is less important than the fact that your publishing is setting everyone else behind

One hallucinated citation does not in any way imply anyone is being left behind. All it means nobody is checked that particular line of the manuscript after it was written. The rest of the paper could still be solid and treated accordingly. If you find evidence of the contrary, of course treat it accordingly, but this is so obviously not that.

show 3 replies