logoalt Hacker News

vrganjtoday at 1:53 PM5 repliesview on HN

But.... why? Like I read his thing on how he spends the tokens [0] and it sounds like satire.

He has agents write shitty code for features other agents think other people want, then has it reviewed by other agents in hopes of catching bugs that the first agent put there, then has some more agents try to find security bugs in the now double-agented code to make it triple-agented and at the end of the day, he spent a shitton of tokens, probably emitted enough carbon to heat our planet by another degree, and has a feature nobody really asked for that might or might not work.

He then has the sense of humor to call this grotesque process "incredibly lean".

What's the point in all of this? What problems is this solving? Who's benefiting?

[0] https://xcancel.com/steipete/status/2055405041843052792


Replies

browningstreettoday at 3:08 PM

I don’t use openclaw myself anymore, but this agonizing is thin and unbearable. He did a thing. People use the thing. He got paid for the thing. He iterates the thing. What’s hard to understand about this?

The morality issues about consumption climate impacts are not his alone, and are not unique by itself to his endeavor. Every company with an enterprise LLM agreement has a share, for instance.

VerTiGo_Etrextoday at 2:39 PM

But this is okay?

“He has /people/ write shitty code for features other /people/ think other people want, then has it reviewed by other /people/ in hopes of catching bugs that the first /people/ put there, then has some more /people/ try to find security bugs in the now /double-peopled/ code to make it /triple-peopled/ and at the end of the day, he spent a shitton of /money, the people/ probably emitted enough carbon to heat our planet by another degree, and has a feature nobody really asked for that might or might not work.”

Honestly sounds like a normal tech company to me. Just with much dumber “people” who are getting exponentially smarter, eventually never die, eventually never forget.

You have to skate to where the puck is going, not where it is.

show 2 replies
simianwordstoday at 2:22 PM

>He then has the sense of humor to call this grotesque process "incredibly lean".

> What's the point in all of this? What problems is this solving? Who's benefiting?

The economy doesn't work like how you think it does. Its not central planning. All the usages aren't detailed in a specification, submitted for approval to 100 agencies and then allowed to be used.

It shows lack of intellectual curiosity to not engage deeply with obviously profound technology and what the implications are. I find this exercise helpful.

Peter is predicting how LLMs will be used in the future when the prices go down. And they will definitely go down. I think his predictions are correct and we will definitely have something similar to OpenClaw.

show 2 replies
estimator7292today at 4:58 PM

[dead]

MagicMoonlighttoday at 2:10 PM

[flagged]

show 2 replies