logoalt Hacker News

solenoid0937today at 3:35 AM3 repliesview on HN

Any argument that a "soul" exists or that consciousness does not arise from the physical world (eg our neurons) is literally unfalsifiable. It cannot be disproven in the same way you can't disprove the existence of God, and so arguing with people that believe in it is largely pointless.


Replies

simionestoday at 9:52 AM

> Any argument that a "soul" exists or that consciousness does not arise from the physical world (eg our neurons) is literally unfalsifiable.

This is an metaphysical discussion, so falsifiability is kind of irrelevant. All metaphysical positions are ultimately unfalsifiable - including materialism and physicalism just as much as dualism or monism or theism.

show 1 reply
andoandotoday at 8:38 AM

Yet the mere fact that I am conscious is a greater truth than any of my perception of the "physical" world.

Neither does pure materialism rest on falsifiable beliefs, in that I could claim nothing exists outside my conscious experience.

aa-jvtoday at 8:14 AM

Argue with someone who gathered evidence scientifically to demonstrate that we really, really don't know what we're talking about when it comes to the human soul:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty_Cases_Suggestive_of_Rei...

EDIT: Downvote all you want, materialists, but reincarnation is the spanner in the works nobody wants to confront ..