logoalt Hacker News

k33ntoday at 3:42 AM3 repliesview on HN

It’s possible that you’re not conscious. So your subjective view may be correct for you. To those who are conscious, this argument doesn’t really matter, and the proof is simply in the pudding.


Replies

solveigatoday at 4:05 AM

If we accept subjective feeling as definitive proof that something exists, that opens a Pandora’s box of entities. People have deeply held subjective beliefs about things like God, afterlife experiences, out-of-body experiences, and many others. It seems unfair to me to dismiss this kind of subjective evidence in these cases, while accepting it without question for experience of consciousness.

thepaschtoday at 4:13 AM

This is a religious argument. If you want to go down that path, then sure; but I suspect that's not what you actually believe.

show 1 reply
anon291today at 3:51 AM

No conscious person can know if another person is conscious. There is no 'sensation' of experiencing another conscious. Given how many people can and have been fooled by AI, this lack of ability to sense another consciousness is clear.

show 1 reply