logoalt Hacker News

The FBI Wants to Buy Nationwide Access to License Plate Readers

178 pointsby cdrnsfyesterday at 7:28 PM70 commentsview on HN

Comments

reenorapyesterday at 8:43 PM

It's probably never going to happen because neither party cares about protecting Americans rights, but we need to have some sort of law that creates a Chinese firewall between these mass surveillance data and the government, or whoever else.

I don't know if you could ever collect this data and never have foreign entities or NSA moles infiltrate into it by sending their agents to work at that company and steal the data whenever they want. But I can see how this would be good at fighting crime but also a completely and absolute destruction of privacy.

We need politicians that actually care about Americans and their rights but no one who cares is dumb enough to want to go into politics, which is the sad thing.

show 1 reply
psadauskasyesterday at 10:28 PM

This will never change until we pass laws that make personal data a liability instead of an asset.

show 1 reply
asdffyesterday at 8:30 PM

In socal people might not even use license plates at all. Some people mask them with a towel or something like that. Some run paper dealership plates which I guess don't need to have any license number on them at all, just the dealer logo. Others just take them off and drive. I've seen plates that were sanded clean and with different numbers stuck on them that don't match then indented numbers.

And then of course all the texas plates. No, it isn't just visitors from texas. Texas has a cool loophole where there is no registration information on the plate, it is on a little sticker on the dashboard. As such, there are a dozen plus cars that have been regulars in my neighborhood for years with texas plates, with some several years old sticker on their dashboard.

It is kind of surprising that they don't get hit with a huge ticket for failing to register their car after 20 days. Some even park on the street quite brazenly. But maybe that shows how these systems are, today at least, very poorly connected between states. I've even seen a car being sold locally where the owner openly admits it was never registered or smogged, and they used it as their local neighborhood runabout just rolling the dice that they would not get pulled over. Just an aspect of the driving culture.

show 2 replies
amanaplanacanalyesterday at 8:13 PM

My local town runs their own license plate readers for red light and speed cameras. Not sure how the feds could get access to those.

show 5 replies
Zigurdyesterday at 10:03 PM

Not that it will help for long distance travel, but if I was running strategy for the big E-bike cartel, I couldn't think of a better meme to promote than the surveillance state getting a chubby about ALPRs.

Seriously, though, I think the Karens out there want E-bike licensed just so cops can keep hassling brown people even when they're not driving clapped out old Toyotas.

show 1 reply
LocalHyesterday at 9:15 PM

If they do, doesn't that make the companies running those readers agents of the state during the collaboration?

show 1 reply
scholarnet-AIyesterday at 8:26 PM

I believe technology is great but we must regulate to assure personal privacy is maintained.

show 1 reply
baggachipzyesterday at 8:13 PM

I had already assumed that they were using Flock data for exactly this. I guess paying to speed the nationwide rollout makes it official and will free them from pesky courts and human rights.

show 1 reply
charcircuityesterday at 9:24 PM

This information can be critical for understanding the movement of vehicles and can benefit law enforcement giving them more evidence and knowledge to work off of. As long as these systems are accurate and not being maliciously tampered with it keeps everyone accountable to their actions.

show 2 replies
god_n_stuffyesterday at 10:32 PM

[dead]

black_13yesterday at 9:48 PM

[dead]

martinbfineyesterday at 10:40 PM

Another AI click bait article. Fake news. And a conspiracy theory.

show 1 reply
NoMoreNicksLeftyesterday at 8:43 PM

Does anyone sell am eInk display that's 12"x6"? Doesn't have to be color, though bonus points for that...

show 1 reply