logoalt Hacker News

awakeasleepyesterday at 10:03 PM2 repliesview on HN

History provides the same answer every time this question arises


Replies

TFNAyesterday at 10:09 PM

> History provides the same answer every time this question arises

You mean that after some popular discontent arises, the top authorities will simply be overthrown by a competing faction within the ruling class, but that competing faction will fool the masses into thinking that “people power” won out and things are any better?

That is, after all, how most “successful” revolutions have played out. Other revolutions that end with the ruling class being completely overthrown often cause the country to collapse into instability that is terrible for quality of life, until a strongman manages to cement his authority.

show 1 reply
Night_Thastusyesterday at 10:05 PM

...it does? This level of automation is recent, and industrialization is the blink of an eye in human history.

If we're talking shorter scale, people have traditionally hand-waived it with 'Oh, these jobs will go away, but they'll be replaced with other, higher-skilled jobs!'.

That's an economist's idealism and doesn't fit reality.

show 3 replies