I didn’t claim that LLMs are people or that they reason.

If the behavior of the llm is the same as the behavior of reasonable people then the behavior of the llm is reasonable, regardless of how black of a box they generate tokens out of.

Reasonable people will generate divergent specs for the same prompt. Thus it is reasonable for an LLM to generate divergent specs out of the same prompt.

Edit: I use “reasonable” here in the legal sense of the “reasonable person” standard, not to imply any reasoning process.