logoalt Hacker News

ikeboyyesterday at 3:14 PM6 repliesview on HN

The path to solving a culture that overincarcerates is not by incarcerating those involved in perpetuating that culture.

We need to tame the impulse to throw people in jail for doing things we dislike, not just point it at different targets.

I see several comments saying that criminal charges should be brought over this. That is not the way.


Replies

ceejayozyesterday at 3:15 PM

We have overincarceration and underincarceration simultaneously.

Some who are in jail should not be. Some who aren't in jail should be. If I locked you up for a month over a meme, I'd go to jail for years.

show 1 reply
digdugdirkyesterday at 3:28 PM

Indeed. Thankfully - as has been proven time and time again in America - if leniency is given to those who abuse their power, they will absolutely never ever decide to abuse their power again.

show 1 reply
BoggleOhYeahyesterday at 3:23 PM

Sure. Let’s start pushing back against over-incarceration by not punishing people that knowingly did something wrong and flies in the face of the country’s supposed values.

Makes sense.

show 1 reply
archonisyesterday at 3:24 PM

If you don't hold people accountable for removing the liberty of others without just cause, those who abuse their power will continue to run rampant.

show 1 reply
gdillayesterday at 3:15 PM

that is literally the way. these maga law breakers need accountability. They got off scott free for j6. we're still fighting the civil war and white fragility because they suffered no consequences the last time.

show 2 replies
dfxm12yesterday at 4:20 PM

This is a grossly disingenuous strawman. The top comment as of posting clearly states "The sheriff that arrested him should face criminal charges for misuse of authority." False imprisonment is against the law, this situation is far from merely doing something we dislike.

show 1 reply