logoalt Hacker News

deatontoday at 3:03 PM6 repliesview on HN

This is an incredibly naive view of intellectual property. If you cannot own things you create, there is little incentive to create and share those things. Do you think any of your favorite movies and TV shows ever get made without copyright protections? Of course not, because money needs to change hands for those things to be funded.


Replies

StableAlkynetoday at 3:26 PM

> If you cannot own things you create, there is little incentive to create and share those things

How do you explain the creative works of writing, music, and art that existed in the millennia of human history between the Mesopotamians and the Enlightenment era?

show 3 replies
ux266478today at 4:53 PM

Is it the pursuit accumulating capital (incentive to profit) or merely to fund something? You switch from the former to the latter. Why do you believe that profit is reliant on copyright? Piracy is so widespread that copyright may as well not exist (in the context of the consumption of media) outside of moralizing rhetoric, and yet insane profits are made all the same.

I cannot at all relate to being so devoid of passions in all categories but the accumulation of capital. If we are to justify copyright and the concept of intellectual property writ large, then as far as I can see its only real usecase is in defending against precisely the people who are possessed by an obsession with capital, those dragons who merely care to see their hoard grow larger. Unfortunately, that's not how these systems are structured in our society. The transferability of intellectual property all but warps the idea into something that instead empowers those it should disarm.

show 1 reply
foobar1726today at 3:08 PM

You should check out this thing called open source software

show 3 replies
nehal3mtoday at 3:08 PM

This is naive in the opposite. Creators gonna create.

show 2 replies
marssaxmantoday at 3:24 PM

Yes, absolutely, and that is why history shows so few examples of any art having been created prior to the invention of copyright: nobody had any reason to do it.

show 1 reply
enraged_cameltoday at 3:11 PM

>> If you cannot own things you create, there is little incentive to create and share those things.

You do realize people created and shared things long before copyright became a thing, right?

show 1 reply