logoalt Hacker News

joshl32532today at 6:45 PM8 repliesview on HN

This is the problem with public listed companies that need to "maximize shareholder values" and look for infinite growth.

I just want Spotify for music (playlist, recommendation, lossless audio). I don't need their podcast, audiobook, ChatGPT, concert tickets etc. This just makes their app bloated for features I will never use.


Replies

something765478today at 7:23 PM

I disagree; Spotify is good at serving up sound, so it makes sense for them to also serve audiobooks and podcasts; just like it makes sense for video streaming services to have both movies and tv shows. Similarly for concerts; people who listen to a lot of music are probably interested in going to see their favorite band live.

Mind you, I definitely have complaints about the app (like notifications interrupting music, their abysmal lock screen widget, and their "randomization" that always ends up playing the same few songs from a list of thousands); but I also understand why they want to expand.

show 3 replies
jmuguytoday at 6:56 PM

Another reason to use Bandcamp and just buy music. Of course then you've gotta setup a whole stack to store it, make it available to your devices, etc etc. I dunno, Spotify certainly isn't going to get better at this point. Best we can hope is that they die and something better takes their place.

show 4 replies
crazygringotoday at 7:21 PM

I understand not wanting them to expand into playlists and audiobooks.

But concert tickets, notifications, etc., seems like a no-brainer. That is firmly within the category of music.

cassianolealtoday at 7:58 PM

It also likely makes it harder for people ho are not users of Spotify to get tickets - which is almost certainly the goal.

rmccuetoday at 7:19 PM

At least concert tickets are somewhat aligned with listening to music, unlike autoplaying video podcasts on the homepage rather than showing my playlists.

electronsouptoday at 6:52 PM

You may need to move on to other services like Apple Music

show 1 reply
crooked-vtoday at 6:46 PM

It's the newest version of Zawinski's Law of Software Envelopment:

> Every program attempts to expand until it can read mail. Those programs which cannot so expand are replaced by ones which can.

dominotwtoday at 6:48 PM

music listening has been falling for a while now. no company public or not will choose to commit suicide out of purity principle

show 1 reply