logoalt Hacker News

serftoday at 2:46 AM1 replyview on HN

less anonymity and a reputation system?

I know you designed the thing, and that was a great effort, but what a miss when compared to the vast majority of freenet users priorities.


Replies

sanitytoday at 3:19 AM

I wouldn't describe it as "less anonymity", it's more that the new Freenet gives applications and users different choices about anonymity depending on their requirements. I don't see how more choice is a bad thing - versus forcing the same (imperfect) solution on everyone as in my original design.

Similarly, reputation systems aren't inherently coercive, they're more analogous to spam filtering or trust heuristics, mechanisms for deciding what to prioritize - but ultimate control always remains with the user.