logoalt Hacker News

joe_mambatoday at 12:48 PM6 repliesview on HN

Economic, market and product results.

Schmidt took Google to the moon financially, speareding projects like Chrome and Android that cemented Google as THE tech titan(couch monopoly cough), whereas Woz was a top HW engineer of his time, but Apple would have quickly failed if he was at the helm calling the shots, instead of Jobs.

From which would you take advice, the successful entrepreneur/investor, or the nice hacker geek who was a one trick pony with the Apple computer but hasn't been in touch with the tech economy and jobs market for decades?


Replies

crispyambulancetoday at 1:04 PM

> From which would you take advice, the successful entrepreneur/investor, or the nice hacker geek [?]

The nice hacker geek? By the way, the Woz has a net-worth of 140MM, so he's more wealthy that the vast majority of "successful entrepreneur/investors", and also vastly more beloved than virtually all of them.

In any case, that's a false dichotomy and actually the wrong question entirely.

show 2 replies
LargeWutoday at 1:00 PM

I want advice from the one questioning whether we should, not just whether we can.

show 1 reply
jjuliustoday at 1:02 PM

Wozniak, every time. Gigantic financial success at the expense of everything Google has negatively impacted isn't something I would be proud of.

Everyone defines success differently, and Schmidt's "success" is, frankly, unappealing and gross to myself and, I'm sure, many others.

There's a lot more to life and the world than the economy and massive financial gains. Focusing on "economic, market and product results" yet mentioning nothing about the impact to people and customers is how Zuckerberg sleeps at night, and that's ugly to me.

amanaplanacanaltoday at 3:30 PM

Dude: Eric schmidt is somebody who turned a cool technology company whose motto was "don't be evil" into an advertising company.

wat10000today at 1:36 PM

I'm fairly allergic to advice in general, but if I were to take some, I'd take it from the happy extremely rich guy over the ridiculous ultra rich guy.

watwuttoday at 1:21 PM

Google turned from company that at least pretends to not do evil ... into one who does it without care.

I think that taking advice from a sociopath able to amass a lot of money is usually bad idea. Their advice is designed to make you make him a lot of money. His advice is not about what is good for you - he does not care. And if you succeed you are his competitor.