logoalt Hacker News

EnPissanttoday at 1:42 PM3 repliesview on HN

What's wrong with letting the citizens of a country have agency in who they allow in? This isn't the gotcha you think it is.


Replies

lanstintoday at 3:23 PM

In this case the people brought up in the United States are sacrificing the well fare of their own children to preserve their own fears. I think that is wrong.

I want to keep the US a destination for hard work and smarts and striking out on your own. Don’t shelter your lazy kid, show them the beauty of complexity and mastery. Have them master some difficult skills, whether that’s a second language or botany or math or public speaking or building things. We are all responsible to each other for excellence. Respond to the opportunities for excellence, of what we can build together, dont’t yield to sloth and resentment being satisfied with turning your back on your own potential. The future is awesome and we welcome all who want to contribute! We welcome competition - better to be second best to the best than turning your back and cutting yourself off from the course of history.

lcnPylGDnU4H9OFtoday at 2:07 PM

If someone says they're not anti immigrant and then turns around to say immigration should be more difficult, there's an obvious logical disconnect in their worldview. It doesn't matter about illegal vs. legal: they want to make immigration more difficult, after claiming they are not against immigration. The comment does not claim there's anything wrong with the policy choice, just that the following policy preference betrays the initial statement as false.

show 2 replies
jfengeltoday at 2:05 PM

Your ability to read isn't what you think it is.

show 1 reply