logoalt Hacker News

nekzntoday at 12:44 PM13 repliesview on HN

Ocean Rise: ~3.2 mm/yr

Land Sinking: + ~8.0 mm/yr

I wonder why CNN have decided to highlight oceans rising and not mention land sinking anywhere in the entire article? Is it possible they have an agenda?


Replies

47282847today at 3:18 PM

Common thinking is that one of these things you can influence, and the other you cannot. You don’t often read articles that mention the sunrise or seasons because they just are, and everybody is already aware of their contribution.

show 1 reply
SoftTalkertoday at 4:09 PM

That was my reaction to the headline. New Orleans is already below sea level. Has been for as long as I can remember. They have adapted to it, you can argue the wisdom of trying to fight the ocean but I'm not sure why they will fail now.

Maybe they can get some investors to fund some big pumped hydro energy storage projects.

postflopclaritytoday at 1:37 PM

NOLA land sinking is also (in large part) due to human activity in draining the wetlands and swamps, so the dry soil starts compressing.

WarmWashtoday at 2:12 PM

Every 24hr news org has an agenda to maximize clicks/views from their ideologically captured herd.

This isn't a left/right thing either.

show 1 reply
karlgkktoday at 1:13 PM

> I wonder why CNN have decided to highlight oceans rising and not mention land sinking anywhere in the entire article? Is it possible they have an agenda?

Because water incursion is a much more difficult thing to deal with, in terms of infrastructure and prevention.

Also, let me know when the rest of coastal land has the same sinking as N.O.

show 2 replies
tobrtoday at 1:37 PM

You can take your tinfoil hat off. In common parlance, ”rising seas” is about relative sea level (RSL), which is what actually matters regardless of the mix of underlying causes. This is how it’s used by e.g NOAA https://tidesandcurrents.noaa.gov/sltrends/faq.html#q1

show 2 replies
opsnooperfaxtoday at 1:24 PM

I wish that there were a Corps of Engineers in the Army, whose job it was to build and maintain water retention structures. I think that such an organization might be our best hope for half an inch of rising water every year. Given that much of the state is already below sea level, that they have not suffered the wrath of climate change could only be a miracle. It must be the work of a merciful God who has forgiven their sins of owning Ford F150s.

show 2 replies
dvhtoday at 12:49 PM

Because land sinking makes only New Orleans unlivable?

daharttoday at 3:02 PM

Is it possible the land is sinking because of the rising water level?

niemandhiertoday at 1:26 PM

See level rise is not the relevant measure.

A single catastrophic event that causes a temporal rise of several meters can permanently alter the coastline and storms are worsening.

show 1 reply
CuriouslyCtoday at 1:45 PM

Sure do. People don't click on land sinking titles.

Hnrobert42today at 12:56 PM

Because we can't do anything about land subsidence.

show 2 replies
dangustoday at 1:00 PM

This humors me: people still think CNN has a “liberal bias” especially as it transitions into ownership by David Ellison.

They probably should have mentioned it, yeah. But if you’re on a sinking ship in the ocean that does mean that the water level is rising relative to you and that is most of your problem.

And are we supposed to not be prepared and informed about the ocean rising at over 3mm per year? I wouldn’t exactly jump to being dismissive of sea level rise that is so dramatic. Every 10 years you’re gaining over an inch, every 100 you’re gaining about a foot. And then you’ve got the ice caps melting which is an impending climate disaster.

In reality, the right-wing criticism of the “mainstream media” has been a form of projection and justification for legitimizing its own propaganda network. Meanwhile, the right denies their own mainstream status: the “mainstream media lies” but the #1 cable news network is a right wing network, the Joe Rogan Experience is the #1 podcast that hosts political guests but isn’t part of the “lying press,” and this is all justification for the FCC to send threatening letters to terrestrial networks for their choice of jokes on late night talk shows or their daytime talk shows not being conservative enough.

CNN misses one detail in a highly scientific story and they get accused of having an agenda, Fox News trots out an employee in a mask pretending to be antifa and nobody bats an eye.

I’m not saying we shouldn’t scrutinize all media, but this particular dynamic is something that has been noticeable.

show 4 replies