logoalt Hacker News

make3today at 3:27 PM1 replyview on HN

No one is saying there isn't, but it's objectively a stupid massive oversimplification of how complex things like a human brain and human learning really are.

For one, people used to be a lot better, do unless you think people are actively dumber, you argument doesn't hold.

School capabilities also correlates massively with things like access to resources and wealth of parents, and inversely with mental health.

We also have very strong incentives as a society, as an economy and as a democracy to have as many educated people as possible, to work on setting the best conditions possible for people to learn


Replies

650today at 4:26 PM

What do you mean people used to do a lot better? As far as I know https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Flynn_effect was a thing until recently.

The human body is quite complex as well.

Graduating a for profit private college that is aiming to maximize profit, by churning out specific degrees does not mean you are educated. Having a college degree is not synonymous anymore with well educated.

The measure (college degree) became a target, and thus it stopped functioning as intended.