logoalt Hacker News

avidiaxtoday at 3:27 PM1 replyview on HN

What is a "fair" outcome?

Is it easier to hold back talented students with a low bar or push untalented ones to a higher bar?


Replies

z3c0today at 3:40 PM

The conundrum of "equality of outcome" vs "equality of opportunity" hinges on that core question. It's weird, and possible contradictory, to see a policy claiming to attempt both.

Most would define a "fair" opportunity as everyone getting the same chances to succeed, but a "fair" outcome would segment on merit. If angling towards fair outcomes, there's usually less uproar over lifting the floor (e.g financial aid), versus lowering the ceiling (e.g. limitations on admissions based on ethnic or financial background).

show 1 reply