logoalt Hacker News

bentcornertoday at 12:30 AM1 replyview on HN

> Also I just find it a little insulting if someone sends me an AI response

I run into this with AI-generated PR comments. I think where I work we are still grappling with the "right point", because LLMs can certainly provide valuable feedback, but they are not at the point where they can do so unsupervised, and to do so just feels unprofessional.

And there's another layer where it is even worse when a colleague spends the time critiquing code and someone (or something) replies to the comment with mostly useless filler. It's like being handed a small hand-crafted gift and then throwing it into the garbage in front of them.


Replies

rogerrogerrtoday at 1:02 AM

I often use LLMs to write or review code, but never ever copy/paste from them into any text box attached to my name.

If my name is posting something, I understand it. If I can read an LLM response and reword it, I understand it.

I really want copying LLM prose into anywhere without a block quote to be a firable offense.