logoalt Hacker News

mrkeentoday at 7:32 AM1 replyview on HN

No, they are function colouring. That's the point.

Someone writes a post lamenting red and blue functions, and everyone eats it up.

Substitute colour for something meaningful and the idea becomes idiotic.

"Top level function declares that it is non-blocking, but when I try to call a small blocking function from it, I have to change the declaration to blocking???"

Yes, yes you do.

Total functions can't call non-total functions.

Deterministic functions can't call nondeterministic functions.

Non-IO functions can't call IO functions.


Replies

captaincrowbartoday at 9:21 AM

‘Non-IO functions can't call IO functions.’

How do you handle logging then? If f() calls g(), how can I add logging to g() without having to change or recompile f() (and everything in the call stack above it)? ‘You can’t’ is not an acceptable answer.