logoalt Hacker News

jocaaltoday at 12:28 PM1 replyview on HN

The system is too big and complex for there to be a notion such as merit. We are animals and just like all animals we must fight to survive. Some people get lucky, some get unlucky. Merit is irrelevant.

And if you try to create a merit based system, you take away the liberties of the people. Who decides what person deserves more than another? You will create a system ripe for corruption.


Replies

Eddy_Viscosity2today at 12:43 PM

> And if you try to create a merit based system, you take away the liberties of the people.

How does a system that rewards people for being good at what they do 'take away liberties'?

> Who decides what person deserves more than another? You will create a system ripe for corruption.

Who decides this now? Its the people who already have more and this has resulted in our existing system being rife with corruption at this very moment.

show 1 reply