logoalt Hacker News

rayinertoday at 2:45 PM7 repliesview on HN

I don't understand this angst over AI replacing humans. We already have models like the Gulf states, where only 10% of the population is citizens and all the work is done by people who are, from the perspective of citizens, quasi-human automatons. That arrangement seems to work fine for the citizens. It seems to me that AI and robots solves the principal problem with that arrangement (the mistreatment of the non-citizen population that does the work).


Replies

folkravtoday at 2:56 PM

You're talking about replacing certain humans with robots. They're talking about replacing humans with robots - final.

asdsgtoday at 3:02 PM

So you trust the guy who gives AI speeches in front of a background that is a mixture of grey neoclassicism and brutalism which Leni Riefenstahl would have been proud of?

https://xcancel.com/LaceyPresley/status/2060436135671632067#...

Here is a hint: Humans are better in dirt conditions. The robots will not take the place of Saudi immigrant workers but rather of the Saudi secret police.

You will be working in the dirt or perhaps be reassigned to fight the Final Beautiful Ground War against whatever the current axis of evil is.

show 1 reply
plastic-enjoyertoday at 2:59 PM

Did you read the article? It's not just about replacing labour with AI but humans as a species to give birth to a machinistic god. The issue is that there is a quasi-religion forming around this ideology, and this are not just a few nutcases but people that are well-connected into industry and politics. Regardless of whether this plan is at all realistic, there is a not insignificant chance that these people will shape society and legislation.

show 1 reply
camillomillertoday at 2:53 PM

So for you the solution is not to dismantle a model like that one but just accept it and displace the quasi-slaves? I swear you people have lost your fucking mind and will push people to violence

show 1 reply
potatototoo99today at 3:28 PM

So you want to be a quasi-AI automaton?

watwuttoday at 2:54 PM

> quasi-human automatons

They are humans. Full on people. They are not quasy humam, they are fully absolutely human

show 2 replies
derektanktoday at 2:56 PM

The gulf countries are the closest thing to socialist states on the planet. Something like 70-90% of the citizenry of Kuwait, Qatar, and Saudi Arabia are employed by the public sector.

show 2 replies